mesophilic starter cubes next to white bowl

How to Make Mesophilic Starter Culture for Cheesemaking?

How to Make Mesophilic Starter Culture for Cheesemaking

Mesophilic starter culture is a cheese culture that works at lower temperatures, roughly 70 to 88°F. It’s what gives cheeses like cheddar, Colby, Monterey Jack, and Gouda their texture and flavor. You can buy it as a freeze-dried powder, or make your own from cultured buttermilk and freeze it in cubes. Here’s how.

Among the ingredients in my traditional mozzarella cheese recipe is mesophilic culture cubes. Which I’m sure most folks don’t need and those of us who do, don’t have on hand. DIY Mesophilic starter culture is so easy to make it just seems silly to go buy comparatively expensive cultures!

Mesophilic starter culture is a low-temperature cultured product. Just like buttermilk and yogurt. It provides cheeses with bacterial organisms that assist in proper curd formation, taste, texture, and aroma. Of course, this means that if your starter culture is off-tasting, your cheese may be off-tasting as well. There is some security (and extra expense) in using prepared mesophilic starter cultures like this one. And different mesophilic starter cultures work best for different types of cheeses. (For example, the one I linked to is good for Cheddar, Jack, and Colby cheeses.)

Knowing how to make your own mesophilic starter culture is useful information. It helps you gain a better understanding of the cheese-making process. Also, it gives you a greater sense of “self-sufficiency” in the event that you can’t get access to prepared cultures. It’s wise to know how to do something the independent way first. Just to have the knowledge filed away.  Once you have learned the new skill set, take advantage of the conveniences available in our modern times. Then you can rest, assured that you’ll know what to do when and if “one day” ever comes.

If you are making cheese from your own milk, a home dairy calendar is a handy place to note what you made and when. That calendar and year-end dairy production records are both in my Homestead Management Printables.

How to Make Mesophilic Starter Culture for Cheesemaking

What Is Mesophilic Culture?

“Mesophilic” means it likes moderate temperatures. Mesophilic cultures do their work when the milk is warmed to roughly 70 to 88°F. Thermophilic cultures are the heat-loving kind, used for cheeses made at higher temperatures.

MesophilicThermophilic
Works best atAbout 70 to 88°FHigher temperatures
Used forCheddar, Colby, Monterey Jack, Gouda, Edam, Muenster, feta, chèvreSwiss, Parmesan, Asiago
Homemade versionCultured buttermilk (this post)Made from yogurt

How to Make Mesophilic Starter Culture for Cheesemaking

  1. Make cultured buttermilk. Follow our cultured buttermilk instructions. It’s ready when it has thickened, usually after 15 to 20 hours at room temperature, around 72°F.
  2. Freeze it in ice cube trays. Use a clean tray so nothing else gets into your culture.
  3. Store the cubes in a freezer bag until you need them (more on food storage here). One cube equals about one ounce of mesophilic culture.

Yep, it’s that easy!

How Much to Use and How Long It Keeps

Always follow the amount your cheese recipe calls for. As a rule of thumb, many home cheesemakers use about 4 cubes (4 ounces) per gallon of milk.

Frozen cubes are best used within about a month. After that, the culture can weaken, and your cheese may not set or ripen as well.

Suggested Read: Essential Guide To Raw Milk (Plus 115 Recipes)

Mesophilic Culture FAQ

What is mesophilic culture?

A cheese starter culture that works at moderate temperatures, roughly 70 to 88°F. It helps the curd form and gives the cheese its flavor and texture.

Can I use buttermilk as a mesophilic starter?

Yes. Cultured buttermilk is the base of this homemade starter.

What cheeses use mesophilic culture?

Cheddar, Colby, Monterey Jack, Gouda, Edam, Muenster, feta, and chèvre, among others.

How long does homemade mesophilic culture last?

Frozen cubes are best used within about a month.

Is homemade as good as store-bought?

It works, but results aren’t as consistent as a manufactured culture, so expect some variation in flavor.

Final Thoughts

Now, the results with homemade mesophilic starter culture will not be as consistent as a manufactured mesophilic starter culture. But if you’re fine with subtle variations in the flavor of your cheese, then this is a perfect, frugal solution!

What cheese will you make next? You should try out this cheddar cheese recipe at home.

Want our from-scratch recipes all in one place? Get the Reformation Acres Cookbook.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

12 Comments

  1. Another way to stretch your Mesophilic culture is to preserve some of the whey (sterilized mason jar?). Next time that you want the same collection of cultures (Mesophilic, Thermophilic, Penicillium), use the whey from the previous batch to inoculate the milk. I have not tried freezing the whey for longer preservation, but it should work.

    This won’t work for lipase (which is an enzyme, and not a culture).

    1. It’s the same process. Whether you’re simply aging it on the counter or adding a starter culture. Actually, if you make it before, you’re making cultured milk (which you could then make into butter and get cultured butter and cultured buttermilk.) We don’t like cultured butter here and make sweet cream butter instead. So I culture the buttermilk after butter making. Hope that explanation helped!

  2. I’m a bit confused. I have a gallon of whole raw milk. I bought some vegetables rennet. So if I buy a quart of cream and make butter, use the butter milk from that ? That has the culture already in it ? Sorry, I’m a bit dense. Lol

    1. Ok, so you can make butter 2 ways- with sweet cream or cultured cream. If you do the cultured cream, the buttermilk is already cultured. Go ahead and use it as your mesophilic starter. If you (like us) think cultured butter tastes funky and prefer to make sweet cream butter, then you culture the buttermilk after making butter. Does that make more sense?

  3. I have read several recipes on making your own mesophilic starter. Most of them have said to add a store-bought mesophilic starter, and boil the jar and, let sit out on the counter, etc.
    But you’re saying that it only takes three steps! Is that all? And it works for you?

  4. I am confused and I think I just did this wrong. :-] I let my milk sit out and then poured half a cup into Buttermilk from the store. It wasn’t until I look at the comments that I saw I was supposed to make butter 1st. So it this batch a dud? Can you clarify what repeat means. Sorry if I seem dense! Thanks for your help.

    1. NO! It’s not a dud! You could use your own buttermilk if you wanted to, but absolutely don’t have to! It’s basically about making a cultured milk product to culture your low temp cheese or other milk products that need a starter culture. I would totally use it! I’ve been away from my computer most of the day and didn’t see your comment until now- I hope you didn’t throw it out yet 🙂

  5. I was wondering how they made aged cheese prior to stores that sold the culture. Lol. Can you use kefir instead of cultured butter milk?

    1. I’ve never tried Wendy, but I don’t see why not. You’ll have to let us know how it works 🙂